Thursday, September 13, 2012

shaken, not stirred.

The other day, one of my daughters asked when we were going to finish shopping for school clothes. I began calculating paydays in my head as I tried to come up with something definitive.  

"Soon," I told her.
She responded by saying this was "stressing her out" and then went on to say, "Well, at dad's I'm used to..."
The words were like nails on a chalkboard. Tin foil on a filling. I'm sure my knee-jerk reaction that followed defied all parenting books. All the stuff I thought I had taken out to the trash had suddenly resurfaced. I yelled. And I said all the stuff that I was used to - like not having to say good-bye to them every other week, sitting down to dinner at the table now shared by her dad and stepmom, and holidays unmarred by "parenting time".  
It was frustration meant for a friend, not my daughter. She has her own wounds and to pile mine on top is unfair. But I was upset. I felt insecure and defensive about not providing at the same level as her father, as petty as that might be.
And, I wasn't really mad at her as she was just being a teen-ager. I was mad at the situation. Mad at my ex. Mad at The Sat with it's broken window and squealing serpentine belt. Mad that I couldn't provide better. Mad at society for all of its materialistic definitions of success and value. Mad that after all the loving and giving and trusting - to a church, to a god, to a man - I got screwed over.  
My daughter got angry. I cried. The next day we went out, just the two of us. We talked it out without all the heated emotions and bought her some mint jeans.
I've since delved into the recesses of my mind reflecting on the details. Why did I get so angry?  Why couldn't I have just been that pragmatic parent that responds with, "Too bad. This isn't dad's house. Stop manipulating," and go about my merry way? It's not like she is wearing shreds. Do I still have the picture in my mind of how life is supposed to be?  Of the mom I am supposed to be?  And, how my daughters are supposed to act?  I only know what I know - what I've seen and how I was raised, all of which have conditioned my instincts. And in an effort to reprogram my instincts, I tried to imagine best case scenarios of how I might handle future situations like this and how to better react, because let's face it, this is life with teen-agers, whether married or divorced. 
And, I thought about being screwed over. Sometimes I feel like I can't say that because it makes me look bad. An unattractive victim. A martyr. In the big picture, my life is so much better.  But, it is what it is and frankly, I did get screwed over. And, I laugh about it and give failing speeches about my car and such, but for whatever reason, it was just one of those days when I felt screwed over. I felt injustice and I couldn't brush it off - and, all the positivity in the world would not have helped. And, in these feelings, I ventured into the past, not to blame and discard responsibility, but to keep sorting, keep making sense of the pain. Because I believe the power does lie within our grasp - to shape our lives into whatever we wish to be, regardless of our pasts. But, at the same time, we are naive to think our environment, heredity, and life's changes do not affect us. Sometimes, shaping our lives requires us to return to the scene of the crime, face the pain, and deal with our issues in order to end up with a self we are happy with tomorrow. 

I read a great blog post today by a guy I follow on Facebook - John Shore. He is an author who writes a lot about toxic Christianity and abuse. In this piece for HuffPost, he is speaking in particular, to Independent Fundamental Baptist (IFB) survivors, but this stuff exists beyond the IFB denomination. Spending much of my adolescent years in a cult with similar expectations (as well as consequences for not following) and then running into a dysfunctional marriage (within the church) at eighteen, I sometimes fight feeling...duped. Gypped. And, frustrated at my naiveté - especially when certain circumstances of the present are a direct result of that naiveté. I feel dumb that I didn't know any better and wonder why it took me so long to see clearly. But, when you're in the vortex and it is done in the name of God or love - when bits of truth are mixed in with the lies - it is easy to get lost. Anyway, I found the following excerpt to be especially validating and comforting during my contemplation. (Though I have a hard time believing that buying into the doctrines and submitting to the abuse is a "sign of strength", and I'm still confused about the lines of self-sacrifice. As far as reasons for one's allegiance to the doctrines being "nothing more than that you love" - not so sure. I don't argue that these victims are, in fact, deeply loving individuals, but I know from experience that codependency also plays a huge part in such loyalty. Other than that, it's good.)
disclaimer: not here to discredit any positive church experiences or healthy relationships. If yours is among them, count your blessings. Bask in the normalcy. I'm not talking about that. I'm talking about closed systems. The absence of checks and balances. Control. Misuse of power. Because I am guessing there are many more who have been there - or, are there. Or maybe church had nothing to do with it. Maybe it was your marriage. Or your own family. Perhaps you trusted. Perhaps your innocence was taken advantage of. You believed they were good, because you're good, because you didn't know such narcissism existed, let alone what the word even meant.
So, without further ado, John Shore...

(for purposes of universality, I've changed Shore's IFB acronym in order to relate beyond survivors of the IFB denomination. My words will be in gray.)
"The one thing I do want to say for anyone just making their way out of the darkness of (IFB) abuse is this: that you once so thoroughly bought into fundamentalism (IFB) is a sign of your strength, not your weakness. Beside the fact that you were likely born into fundamentalism (IFB) and so never chose to believe anything about it one way or another, your allegiance to it (IFB) means nothing more than that you love. You love passionately, deeply and inexorably. And like everyone else in the world you want that love to mean something, to be incorporated into and desired by something worthy of it. And what can possibly be more worthy of a person's love than God and family?
You brought the goods to the table. You showed up, ready to play. You brought the best of yourself. You brought all of yourself.
You gave. You trusted. You loved, and loved, and loved some more. You loved when you had no more love to give.
You loved when the cost of that love was to negate the best parts of yourself.
You did what you were supposed to do: you sacrificed yourself.
It was they who didn't truly commit to the truths upon which they claimed to be basing their lives. It was they who lied -- first to themselves, and then to you.
They didn't sink deep enough. They didn't give over their will [to God]. They didn't sacrifice who they were.
They kept what they wanted. They kept what they needed. They kept what worked for them.
They pretended to be something they weren't. They insisted upon that ignoble facade despite the too-clear harm it was causing. For their own dark reasons they kept that wicked dance going.
They lied.
They lied, they lied, they lied.
And they used the best of who you are, and the best of what you have to give, to feed those lies.
They used you as fodder in the war between themselves and everything they fear.
And because of your trusting love for them, you let them. You served them that way. You loved them in that (and a million other) ways. And in a real and important sense you will always love them. And out of that love you gave them the best of who you are to do with whatever they felt they needed to. And if they failed to treat that greatest of gifts with the sacrosanct respect it deserves, then shame on them.
If they really loved [God] they would have loved you and everyone else in a manner befitting that love: properly, carefully, consistently. It really is that simple.
Here's the best part...
And despite all you've been through, here you are now! Dented, maybe, a little -- but definitely not broken.
Slightly wobbly, but still on your feet.
Shaken, not stirred.
You were right; they were wrong; and no sane person in the world would say otherwise. And screw 'em if they do.
You have left them now to themselves, and stepped into your own world. A world where you say what is and isn't good. Where you write the rules. Where you claim what's true.
Finally, now, it's time for you to dance to your own song.
And how marvelous will be your dance.
How you will soar."

for the complete article, click here.

14 comments:

The Everyday Healer said...

Really needed this. Thank you yet again! Hugs.

Jamie said...

wow.

I'm not sure I can find the right words to express just how deeply I feel this post.

I've been fighting to heal the psychological scars that molded my emotional and behavioral habits, and sometimes I get so angry. the shaming, the bullying, the sense of self-worthlessness that was pounded into me was so... wrong. and I feel duped, I feel cheated, because I wonder what kind of person could I be now if I hadn't spent so long hating myself because that's what they said was right?

"you loved when the cost of that love was to negate the best parts of yourself."

that is, exactly, how I feel. thank you for sharing this.

Kathy said...

When I'm feeling slayed by my evangelical background, the breath that brings me back to life is remembering that I stopped the cycle. It ended with me and won't be haunting my children's lives like it has mine. We can't change our past but we do have the power to show these beautiful young ones a life without chains and judgement. How cool is that?!

Marian Hazel said...

Oh Carin, that's so tough. Teenage girls have some serious attitude. Rob's daughter has only recently started to talk to him again after a few years of terrible, terrible non-communicion. It's hard for him too, cause we rarely see her, and the time spent with him has never been a priority for her mother or her. Which is so sad. Yet whenever there is a cost involved in anything (school, health, clothes etc), or she doesn't feel her presents were enough, we cop it. We always provide, but sometimes it hurts that she will only see us if she "gets" something. It's certainly getting better, but still you feel trapped by the situation, and either way we seem to get in trouble.
Co-parenting is certainly not an easy road.
You know how I feel about being screwed over by the church environment I came out of. Hoping your weekend is a good one.

Carey King said...

I'm not sure why my comments keep deleting themselves, arg, but last try. when I read your post this morning I wanted to sit in your orange kitchen chair and have a cup of tea with you. I'm in a happy marriage, and my parents are the kind that everyone adopts as their own- but it has been very messy at times and I've learnt the scariest truths about marriage but also the good ones. My parents got saved just before they got married and we've always been in non-denominational churchs and my parents have never changed from being fun, quirky and chilled- I am so grateful for that and growing up being encouraged to learn about all aspects of life and belief. Maybe its later than you wanted to discover it but thats the freedom you're handing to your children:) All your photo's from your last post make in clear to see the peace and happiness pouring into your life..
So yea, wanted to send my love and general encouragement:)

Kulio said...

Ugh, yes, been there. I have the exact same feeling of wishing I could respond like Matt does to the kids, just shrugging and saying, "Nope, you can't have it, there's no money for that, suck it up." But my first response can be to kind of blow up -- angry with them, maybe, for being grouchy about what they can't have...but mostly angry at myself for not pulling it all together and figuring out a way for them to have a pair of Toms like "everybody else".
Anyway, I do get the phrase, "...is a sign of your strength, not your weakness" -- I've always said that I'd rather hope and hope and love and be crushed and have my heart broken..than to never risk it. I think trusting is a kind of risk that is a sign of strength. And if it's wasted on someone or something (like a bogus religion), it's not a reflection on you -- it's a reflection on them -- they weren't worthy of your beautiful love and trust.
So then we get "wiser", I guess, and more cynical as we get older, and rue decisions, and feel duped...but if there's any way to hold on to that amazing ability to trust -- we will end up to be the strongest ones left in the end.
You were the strong one. What hurt you was their weakness--their inability to live up to the powerful strength of your love. :-) Anyway, I have a friend from high school who was completely abused by IFB as a child and young adult - she got out, but I remember attending a funeral with her, and we knew some of the members would be there. Another friend and I literally stood guard so that we could physically keep them from getting to her in any way. I felt kind of awesome to be there as her guard :-) I'm remembering it now because of this post, but it's making me think of how cool it is to have friends who've got your back, and who take seriously your capacity to trust.

Kristen Maddux said...

You’ve got some seriously awesome commenters here, Carin. Such understanding, articulate friends giving you lots to think about on your journey. Amazing!

I don’t blame you at all for feeling duped/used/victimized because, frankly, it sounds like you were. And I hate that for you. Victimization of any kind makes me want to vomit. And that being done in the name of God? Inexcusable. Because you’re right…when it’s done in the name of God/the Bible there is all sorts of real truth mixed in there that only leads to things being really screwed up when you’re trying to figure out why so much seems so WRONG. At least if it was pedophilia or some other sort of blatant abuse one could just file it under “pure evil” and be done with it (in that respect.)
I’ve seen what you are describing up close and personal. Not in my life growing up (thank GOD), but in some of my friends’ lives. And let me tell you, as adults, they’re scarred too. No one walks away from childhood mental manipulation like that unscathed.
In chatting with one of my friends about it (who has now, after much counseling and courage) come to the other side….she said a healing thought to her was when she realized that these people she trusted/listened to are not God. He is a far different being than all that nonsense. And He hates what people do “in His name” too. Now that last sentence opens a whole other can of worms, but there’s her take on her experience, for what it’s worth.
I just love reading your heart. I love that you’re bold enough to talk these things out. And I’m interested to see where your journey leads you.
Oh and yes, that was some classic teenage manipulation right there! Brilliant. Teens don’t hesitate to pull out the low blows, man. But I love them anyway! Glad you all got to talk things thru.

Unknown said...

Your words, and those you share with us that we might not see that come from your inspirations....I hate that real emotion inspired them, but I love how you say it.

Becky at lifeoutoffocus said...

Love you. Love this. That is all. Truly. Gonna pass this onto a friend who's been doubting church lately.

Elissa said...

I love this! "DEFINITELY NOT BROKEN!!!" And there is joy in showing that truth to the world! Thanks for sharing.

tomsgirl1129 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
hb said...

religious abuse is among the worst of abuses. there are no words to help ease the pain of it but: I'm sorry and: it is WRONG. love ya...

Anonymous said...

Hi! I've been following your blog for a little while now and I just wanted to say that I so admire you for your honesty and commitment to, no matter how difficult, making your life the one you want.

You definitely are no victim.

Luisa said...

I so needed this right now I'm in the heat of things in the middle of an ugly divorce never thought that would happen but it is. I'm following your blog now just because of this post.

Oh and the parenting with your teenager sometimes they may not be our finest momenets *ahem* but I have learned they can be growing moments to go back to and talk about.